Immigration Litigation & Home Office Challenges
Immigration litigation is the legal process of challenging immigration decisions, actions or failures by public authorities through the courts and tribunals. It can include immigration appeals, judicial review proceedings, urgent legal applications and challenges concerning the lawfulness of Home Office decisions.
Where an immigration application has been refused, an appeal has been unsuccessful, or the Home Office has failed to act in accordance with the law, it may be possible to pursue a legal remedy.
ICS Legal provides immigration advice and representation, including assessing the merits of legal challenges, preparing detailed representations and advising on judicial review proceedings.
What is Immigration Litigation?
Immigration litigation concerns legal disputes involving immigration law, nationality law and decisions made by public authorities. These disputes may arise where the Home Office has refused an application, delayed making a decision, failed to follow published guidance, or exercised its powers unlawfully.
Immigration litigation may involve:
-
Appeals against qualifying immigration decisions.
-
Administrative reviews of eligible Home Office decisions.
-
Judicial review of unlawful decisions or actions.
-
Pre-Action Protocol correspondence.
-
Challenges involving immigration detention, removal or deportation.
-
Urgent applications for interim relief.
Not every immigration refusal can be challenged through judicial review. The correct procedure depends on the decision, the available statutory remedies and the particular circumstances.
When can a Home Office decision be challenged?
A Home Office decision may be challenged where there is a recognised legal basis for doing so. Examples may include:
-
An incorrect interpretation or application of immigration legislation.
-
Failure to follow applicable Immigration Rules.
-
Failure to consider relevant evidence.
-
Procedural unfairness.
-
Unreasonable or irrational decision-making.
-
Failure to comply with applicable human rights obligations.
-
Unlawful delay or failure to make a decision.
The existence of an error does not automatically mean judicial review is the appropriate remedy. It is necessary to consider whether an appeal, administrative review or other adequate remedy is available.
What Is Judicial Review in immigration law?
Judicial review is a legal procedure through which a court or tribunal examines the lawfulness of a decision, action or failure to act by a public authority. In immigration matters, judicial review may be used to challenge certain Home Office decisions where no adequate alternative legal remedy exists.
The purpose of judicial review is not ordinarily to substitute the court's preferred immigration decision for that of the Home Office. Instead, the court examines whether the public authority acted lawfully, followed proper procedures and exercised its powers within the limits of the law. Where a challenge succeeds, the court may quash the unlawful decision and require the authority to reconsider the matter lawfully.
Legal grounds for Immigration Judicial Review
Illegality
A decision may be unlawful where the Home Office has misunderstood the law, applied the wrong legal test, exceeded its statutory powers or failed to apply relevant legal requirements.
Procedural Unfairness
Procedural unfairness may arise where an individual has been denied a fair opportunity to respond to relevant allegations or where a legally required procedure has not been followed.
Irrationality or Unreasonableness
A decision may be challenged where it meets the demanding legal threshold for irrationality or public-law unreasonableness.
Disagreement with the Home Office's assessment does not, by itself, establish irrationality.
Human Rights and Proportionality
Where applicable human rights are engaged, a legal challenge may concern whether the decision unlawfully interferes with protected rights.
Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights may be relevant in cases involving private and family life.
The applicable legal test depends on the statutory framework and the particular rights engaged.
Pre-Action Protocol before Judicial Review (PAP)
Before commencing judicial review proceedings, the proposed claimant should ordinarily consider the Pre-Action Protocol for Judicial Review. This procedure provides an opportunity to explain the legal challenge and allow the public authority to reconsider its position before proceedings are issued.
A Pre-Action Protocol letter may include:
-
The decision or conduct being challenged.
-
Relevant immigration and procedural history.
-
The factual and legal basis of the proposed challenge.
-
The alleged errors of law or procedure.
-
The remedy requested.
-
Relevant supporting documents.
-
A proposed deadline for a response.
The Home Office publishes a standard template for immigration and nationality cases. A Pre-Action Protocol letter does not automatically suspend a removal decision or extend the deadline for commencing judicial review. Where removal is imminent or other urgent circumstances exist, ordinary pre-action correspondence may be inappropriate.
Immigration Judicial Review time limits
Judicial review proceedings in England and Wales must generally be commenced promptly and, in most cases, no later than three months after the grounds for the claim first arose. The three-month period is an outer limit, not an automatic entitlement to wait three months.
Different or shorter deadlines may apply in particular proceedings or jurisdictions. Sending a Pre-Action Protocol letter does not stop time running. Applicants should obtain legal advice as soon as possible after receiving a decision or becoming aware of the conduct they wish to challenge.
Judicial Review in the Upper Tribunal or Administrative Court
Most immigration judicial review claims in England and Wales fall within the jurisdiction of the Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber). However, certain proceedings must be brought in the Administrative Court.
These may include challenges concerning the lawfulness of immigration detention, certain nationality decisions and challenges to the validity of Immigration Rules or legislation. Determining the correct forum is an important part of preparing a judicial review claim.
What happens during Judicial Review proceedings?
Judicial review generally involves several stages.
1. Legal assessment
The proposed challenge is reviewed to establish whether there are arguable grounds and whether another adequate remedy exists.
2. Pre-action correspondence
Where appropriate, a formal letter is sent to the Home Office explaining the legal issues and the remedy sought.
3. Issuing proceedings
If the dispute remains unresolved, proceedings may be commenced in the appropriate court or tribunal.
4. Permission stage
The court or tribunal considers whether the claim should proceed to a substantive hearing.
5. Substantive proceedings
Where permission is granted and the case is not otherwise resolved, the court or tribunal considers the legal challenge.
6. Judgment or resolution
The matter may conclude through a judgment, settlement, withdrawal or another procedural outcome.
A successful judicial review does not necessarily result in the immigration application being granted. The Home Office may instead be required to reconsider the matter in accordance with the law.
Urgent immigration litigation and removal cases
Urgent immigration litigation may arise where a person faces imminent removal from the United Kingdom or where another decision requires immediate legal intervention. Depending on the circumstances, an urgent judicial review application and request for interim relief may be necessary.
The existence of a pending legal challenge does not automatically prevent removal or detention. Urgent cases require immediate consideration of the relevant legal remedies, procedural requirements and available evidence.
Immigration Appeals, Administrative Review and Judicial Review
These procedures serve different legal purposes.
- An immigration appeal is available where legislation provides a right of appeal. The tribunal considers the case within its statutory jurisdiction.
- Administrative review is a Home Office process available for specified eligible decisions, principally concerned with identifying caseworking errors.
- Judicial review is a supervisory legal procedure concerned with the lawfulness of public-authority decisions or conduct.
Choosing the appropriate procedure is essential because the availability of an adequate alternative remedy may affect whether judicial review is appropriate.
How ICS Legal can assist with immigration litigation
ICS Legal advises individuals and families facing complex immigration decisions and potential legal challenges.
Our services may include:
-
Assessing immigration refusals and decision letters.
-
Identifying possible errors of law or procedure.
-
Reviewing applicable Home Office guidance and policies.
-
Advising on immigration appeals and administrative review.
-
Preparing Pre-Action Protocol correspondence.
-
Assessing the merits of judicial review.
-
Preparing legal representations and supporting evidence.
-
Coordinating appropriate court or tribunal representation.
-
Advising on urgent immigration matters.
We assess each case individually and explain the available remedies, relevant deadlines, potential costs and legal risks.
Obtain immigration litigation advice
If you have received an adverse Home Office decision or believe that an immigration decision has been made unlawfully, ICS Legal can assess your circumstances and advise on the available options.
Resources & references
The content has been written in line with the following policy law and guidance’s. Any changes are updated in the following:
-
Litigation - CPR - https://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/civil/rules/part54.
- Upper Tribunal - https://www.judiciary.uk/courts-and-tribunals/tribunals/upper-tribunal/upper-tribunal-immigration-and-asylum-chamber/.
Author
The contents on this page has been written by a qualified Lawyer at ICS Legal. We are a regulated law firm in the UK by the Immigration Advice Authority. ICS Legal have been advising & helping our client's since 2006. You can find all our information related to our regulatory bodies here.
Stay connected with us on LinkedIn.
Legal Disclaimer
We update our pages with information to confirm the date/time this page had been updated on the top. However the information provided here is for general purposes and does not constitute legal advice.
This also does not create a client-Lawyer relationship based on the contents of our pages. We recommend that you either speak to the Home Office or our Lawyers at ICS Legal to take advice on your matter before you proceed on an application.